Letters of the week November 6, 2026

Olive branch extended

Dear Echo News,

In answer to the recent ‘Olives Trees out of control’ letter from R Carson of Bennett Springs.

Allow me to extend an olive branch to you.

The olive is a fruit and a much revered one at that as it has been part of religious ceremonies and culture throughout the different civilisations that have come before us.

I gather in Italy there are six hundred varieties or perhaps even more. In Spain, Turkey, Greece, Morrocco, Australia, United States of America, South America, South Africa, China and Japan olives are also grown.

Yes indeedy, the world loves olives.

I have an olive tree on my verge and as it shades the passerby it reminds people of the country that they have left behind to come and work in Midland on the meatworks, the rail works, the factories and all other occupations that were here in the 1950s onward.

It is a comfort. When I first came to this area I had never grown a tree in my life and certainly not an olive tree.

I drew a plan of how I was going to create my garden and talked about my heritage and my family history of my mother who always planted an olive tree each place that she lived in and applied to the council to grow one.

So. I got my olive tree. The first one was removed, the second was root bound and the third I went and bought and it is now flourishing, fruiting and the other day I noticed a bird’s nest in the branches.

A woman that moved here 50 years ago from Calabria taught me to pickle the olives and now I teach the people that live nearby as well as people that pass by as it is easy and simple to create as part of your pantry.

Sometimes I give a passing stranger a jar which I will say brightens up their day.

So, an olive tree can bring together and create a community.

We also need trees for food, shade and a home for birds and other animals and cities need that canopy as there is going to be higher temperatures and less rainfall in some areas.

I am appalled at the idea of olive trees being poisoned and destroyed as all living life deserves respect and a right to live.

A Brown

Guildford

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Data centre protests

Dear Echo News,

I notice that when protesting against the CDC data centre establishment, it  appears that a certain generation seem to participate.

The younger generation, that it will affect most, do not seem to consider the vast damage that will occur and the wildlife to the natural landscape.

On another subject I have lived in Viveash since 2003.

It is a nice area to live but I am finding it a bit constricting now with all the developments going on and I wish they made the streets a little wider.

Also, I believe that the street curbs in Viveash and surrounding Midland roads should be limited to the width.

That would allow for more vehicles to park off road.

Unfortunately, we have in many households in Viveash between three to six vehicles parked in the front of a lot of new homes.

Love development - but time and eras change and so do we have to accommodate change.

R Mungioli

Viveash

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Council collective amnesia

Dear Echo News,

On October 27, Kalamunda councillors lined up to tell residents there had never been a caravan park planned for the heritage-listed Carmel Schoolhouse which has been used by the scouts since 1992.

“There is no proposal for a caravan park at this site,” said Cr David Modolo. “The council has not said it’s going to be a caravan park. It’s never said that,” said Mayor Margaret Thomas.

Cr Josh Clark said: “Misinformation fills the vacuum”. Deputy Mayor Kathy Ritchie was “not sure where that’s come from.”

I can help. It came from them.

On June 23, every councillor present voted to endorse the city’s confidential business case for the site.

Its preferred option is titled ‘Delivery of a camping and caravan ready site (ground lease)’.

A caravan park is currently prohibited there, so the business case recommends amending the planning scheme to allow, in its own words, “caravan park usage”. It seeks, “an experienced operator from the caravan and camping sector”.

The officer’s report in that night’s public agenda refers to camping or caravan use in 12 places.

The business case, since released under FOI, adds at least 11 more.

A concept plan prepared in February shows 15 caravan sites. That same night, deputy mayor Ritchie asked officers how the scouts would fare beside “a caravan park with a shop”.

On October 27, councillors had the chance to undo the June decision.

The revocation motion would have shelved the business case, cancelled the expression of interest and offered the scouts a new lease.

It was lost, six votes to three. The Mayor and deputy mayor were among the six.

So, the June decision stands: the market test goes ahead, and the scouts, who have cared for the schoolhouse since 1992, remain on a holdover lease with no new lease on offer.

The business case council endorsed recommends ‘ceasing any further lease or licence agreements’ for the site and plans for their ‘vacating, and site handover’.

The 100 or so residents, scouts and parents who packed the schoolhouse on October 7 did not misunderstand anything. They understood the city’s own documents.

Councillors are entitled to change their minds. They are not entitled to rewrite the record.

In November they should correct it, and publish the business case so every ratepayer can read it.

B Dornan

Wattle Grove

Privately owned, proudly independent local news service.

ALL IMAGES & WORDS © 2023 Echo Newspaper
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram