
Bikes and heritage trails
Dear Echo News,
You recently published an article titled e-bike use concerns on Mundaring heritage trail.
On October 23 you printed a letter titled Limit speed on heritage trail.
Bicycles and e-bikes limited to 25 kmh while under power are both legal on trails, shared paths, roads etc.
What isn’t legal in areas like the heritage trail are modified or de-restricted e-bikes that have the speed limitation removed, and throttle-controlled devices that look like bicycles but don’t require pedalling for motion.
These latter are actually motorcycles (motorbikes), and should be named as such (not just lumped into the group named ‘e-ridables’), require licenses for both rider and vehicle. All motorcycles are not permitted on the heritage trail.
Tyre and wheel size, and bicycle style (gravel bike or otherwise), are not relevant.
What is relevant, as pointed out in the response letter, is the rider’s attitude.
Groups of riders taking the whole trail width (and speeding individuals), frequently treating the trail like a personal race track, are inconsiderate at best and dangerous at worst.
Setting a speed limit is impractical and unlikely to be enforced, unfortunately, so it is almost inevitable that serious injuries will happen.
But it is not just the group riders that are inconsiderate and abusive; group walkers also spread out across the trail, frequently with their eyes on their phones and meandering aimlessly (why bother being there if they’re not interested in their surroundings?), and wander into the path of riders then abuse the rider if they are startled.
Unsupervised small children wandering aimlessly, or learning to ride bikes, are also potentially dangerous to riders (and themselves).
Unfortunately self-centred, entitled and inconsiderate people are becoming more common, and cause angst and potentially dangerous situations for ordinary users of the heritage trail.
L Atkins
Parkerville
--------------------------------------------------------------------Ward boundary meeting
Dear Echo News,
The City of Swan special electors meeting on Monday, November 9 was an interesting exercise and an unexpectedly wonderful opportunity to observe what appeared to be stacking and stooges in an attempt to sway voting.
The meeting was called by concerned electors in the Midland/Guildford ward, in relation to the deeply flawed 2026 ward boundary discussion paper, all of which could have been very quickly resolved several weeks ago, by the city administration admitting to the unintentional errors and inadvertent non-presentation of all known options, then adjusting the paper accordingly, however the council in its wisdom, appeared to prefer an adversarial path.
It was interesting to hear the mayor instruct attendees that those speaking should not reflect adversely on council members or city employees, but subsequently allow one speaker the freedom to accuse several council members of arranging the meeting in order to gain financially, further accuse them of not attending previous meetings and then give a long and glowing reference to councillor Bowman!
I am of course, absolutely certain it was just pure coincidence, as was the block of people from other wards seated across the front rows, all there, as the show of red cards demonstrated, to disallow the motion.
One erstwhile chap explained that voters were not interested in ward changes, rather they were concerned with the cost of living and keeping council rates down, therefore the motion should be disallowed.
I spent some time door knocking re the motion and my conclusion was that people were shocked and angry at the proposed ward changes, but the weekly strain of cost of living issues, combined with a general disillusionment with politics and politicians on all levels, meant they had given up on even bothering to vote.
However, they were very glad to have their attention drawn to the matter and that people were working on their behalf.
The motion was passed with a very healthy majority, but it may well be a hollow victory, as such motions are not binding on councils and this is not a council historically given to listening to and acting on behalf of electors.
Perhaps the next step, should the council decide that rectifying mistakes and providing all reasonable options to electors is not an option, is for voters to demand early elections across the City of Swan.
G Ross
Swan View
--------------------------------------------------------------------European olives are invasive
Dear Echo News,
A Brown’s Olive branch extended letter is a lovely account of this wonderful plant and its significance to many people across the globe, and I thank them for reminding us of that.
One could write similar letters about other weeds such as Watsonia and especially Arum lilies, both personal favourites of mine due to their lovely flowers.
However, when you get an eye for the ecosystem damage caused by these and many other weeds which get into our bush reserves you can’t unsee the devastation they often cause.
This is particularly upsetting when the plant out of place is hard to remove, such as figs or Flinders Range wattles.
European olives are highly invasive weeds in south-west WA.
Birds spread them into bushland where they compete with native plants for light, water and nutrients, and increase bushfire risks through volatile oils.
Left uncontrolled, olives can displace native vegetation, suppress the regeneration of our beautiful wildflowers, and reduce the diversity of native plants.
Olives are particularly difficult to eradicate due to their extensive roots and vigorous resprouting, and they require years of control and follow-up to tackle regrowth and new seedlings.
Gardeners have the right to plant almost anything but will they accept the responsibility to pull them up when they spread?
Please don’t say, “Not my problem, that’s council land,” if your plants are getting away.
MD Jones
Jane Brook
Catchment Group Incorporated