
THE City of Swan council has requested a planning improvement plan be presented in February next year following an independent review of the city’s planning processes.
The request formed part of an amended motion passed 10–5 at the November 11 council meeting.
The LK Advisory review examined the city’s planning framework and four cases, including the Hazelmere data centre, The Vines structure plan amendment and Midway Ford’s non-conforming use application.
It produced 39 priority recommendations and found the city’s processes generally aligned with the state planning framework, while identifying procedural weaknesses it considered unlikely to have materially affected planning outcomes.
City of Swan planning and development executive director Leon Van der Linde said the first priority was a comprehensive policy review.
He said this would address inconsistencies between local policies and deemed provisions, which prevail over inconsistent planning scheme provisions, and form part of the improvement plan.
Cr Jennifer Catalano questioned why deficiencies had occurred if planning staff were already following the state framework and recognising the precedence of deemed provisions.
Mr Van der Linde said the identified deficiencies concerned processing, including accepting information and ensuring the correct material was available during public advertising.
He distinguished those issues from assessing applications on their merits, which fell outside the review’s scope.
Cr Catalano then asked whether the proposed interim controls were redundant because they covered requirements staff were already applying.
Mr Van der Linde said they were not redundant and that he and the statutory planning manager could reinforce the requirements and introduce steps to ensure assessments addressed the state framework.
Cr Sarah Howlett’s amendment requesting priority implementation of interim controls passed unanimously and became part of the substantive motion.
Cr Rod Henderson subsequently added an amendment for council to form a planning process and policy improvement committee at its February 2027 meeting.
Supporting implementation, Cr Bowman pointed to reviewer Len Kosova’s experience and said the report fulfilled the scope commissioned by the committee.
“And let me remind you about Len Kosova, one of the most well-known, respected, and experienced planning people in WA,” he said.
He described the report as a roadmap for improving the city’s planning processes and urged councillors to begin implementing its recommendations.
As reported in Swan council backs planning department review, the review originated from an annual elector’s meeting where residents voted unanimously for an independent review.
The Vines resident and former state parliamentarian Gavan Troy initiated the review at the City’s Annual Elector’s meeting in February.
“The report has enabled Councillors to understand serious shortcomings in the city’s planning processes and appreciate the need for these issues to be addressed with some urgency,” Mr Troy said.
Community groups coordinator Dixon Lowe said residents supported an improvement program but disputed some of the review’s conclusions.
“The reviewer acknowledged the deficiencies are systemic, with some written into the city’s own procedures,” Mr Lowe said.
“Our community group doesn’t support the review’s conclusion that the city’s processes are ‘aligned with the state planning framework and represent good practice’, nor that the deficiencies didn’t alter planning outcomes.
“These statements conflict with evidence reported and leave statutory compliance questions unresolved.”
Mr Lowe said the community endorsed the recommendations, subject to two proposed amendments, as the basis for improvements to governance, statutory compliance and public confidence.
Council’s resolution noted the community submissions for staff consideration in preparing the improvement plan.
It also provided for council to consider reporting arrangements when the plan is presented in February.