
CARMEL Scouts’ future at the heritage-listed Carmel Schoolhouse remains uncertain after Kalamunda council rejected a motion to stop wider market testing for the site and progress a new lease for Scouts WA.
The October 27 motion, moved by Cr John Giardina, would have reversed council’s June 23 decision but it was defeated 6-3.
The scouts have used the property at the corner of Carmel and Reeds roads since 1992.
They remain under a holdover arrangement after their lease expired in June 2023.
During public question time on October 27, the city confirmed it had received an expression of interest from the scouts.
Cr Giardina’s motion proposed forming an advisory group of six surrounding or adjoining landowners and up to two Scouts WA representatives, with support from city staff.
Under point five, the city would have worked at the same time to progress a draft lease for Scouts WA by June 2027.
Cr Giardina said residents at an October 7 community meeting had told him they should have been consulted earlier.
“And all I heard on the night, the majority was, ‘We weren’t informed and we weren’t told,’ and fair enough, that was true,” he said.
“So I don’t mind putting my hand up and saying, ‘Look, we got it wrong this time. Let’s go back and try again.’ So that’s what I’m doing here this evening.”
City of Kalamunda Mayor Margaret Thomas said she wanted to hear how the scouts would use the facility before the city proceeded with a lease.
“I want to discuss with the scouts how they’re going to make good use of that, not just say execute the lease. So, I’m not supporting this because of point five,” she said.
“But that doesn’t mean I don’t want scouts there.”
The city’s June officer report examined several options for the 2.03ha site, including keeping the current arrangement, returning it to state management and exploring visitor uses.
One option involved changing the planning scheme to allow camping and caravan use, then seeking an operator through a ground lease.
Cr Modolo said the city had yet to receive a commercial proposal for the site.
“There is no proposal for a caravan park at this site,” he said.
“There is no commercial proposal on the table at all.”
Ms Thomas said the city was preparing a pre-EOI community engagement phase expected to launch before December.
“As part of this process, local landholders, residents and interested stakeholders will be invited to provide feedback on what they value about the site and what elements should be protected,” she said.
“The engagement will also seek community feedback on the types of opportunities they would be comfortable seeing explored through the EOI process.”
The community engagement period is expected to run until mid-January 2027, with the EOI anticipated to be released in February 2027.
“No decision has been made regarding the future use of the site,” Ms Thomas said.
“The upcoming EOI process is intended to explore potential opportunities for the site and identify proposals that align with the city’s objectives, heritage obligations, planning requirements and community values.
“The EOI will not determine an outcome.
“The city acknowledges the strong interest in the Carmel Schoolhouse and recognises the site’s significance to many people within the community.
“Community feedback gathered through the pre-EOI engagement process, along with any future consultation on preferred options, will help inform recommendations presented to council for consideration.