Letters of the week October 30, 2026

Olive trees out of control

Dear Echo News,

I write relating to planting and maintenance of Olive Trees in the Bennett Springs area and widely in other areas managed by the City of Swan.

Roughly 23 years ago Bennett Springs was developed as a new suburb, and the landscape plan was for native plants.

After I moved into my home the City of Swan planted street trees including over 100 olive trees. I questioned this as they are dangerous planted near areas of natural vegetation.

The fallen olives and olives from the trees are carried by birds to large native trees and after eating the olive the seed is pooped out.

This is perfect for establishing olive seedling which grow into large olive trees.  They will continue to grow for a hundred years and continually fruit.

Take a look at the size of the olive tree at Government House which is a testament to the size height and width after being managed by a team of certified arborists for many years.

I objected to the olive trees being planted after they commenced to fruit and asked for them to be removed and replaced with suitable native plants.

My request was denied.

As they grew the olive and litter drop was enormous - tonnes a year.

I requested a weekly cleanup by the city and was denied.

As mentioned in their policy documents, they are not responsible for cleanup of fallen fruit and litter.

The olive tree is identified as a woody weed in many jurisdictions throughout Australia.

The Margaret River Nature Conservation Group embarked a program to fully remove all olive trees growing on roadside verges and educate property holders to remove and destroy the trees.

They have exactly documented and have a leaflet explaining how to remove and poison them to ensure they are properly destroyed.

I’m a member of the group who are proactive and lawfully removing the trees.

All I have ever wanted from the City of Swan is an outcome, but they seem to want to argue and not answer any questions asked, then accuse me of wasting their time.

I have never wasted their time and if they acted professional, ethically and gave clear honest advice we would not be in this mess. They have refused to talk to me from the outset.

I won’t give up the fight to have these olive trees removed.

When gone I hope the community who have given me their continual support will understand I did my best to get the desired outcome.

R Carson

Bennett Springs

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Need for police on bikes

Dear Echo News,

I am writing about the idea of bike police in the city of Midland and riding in the inner city from the area centred around Midland Gate and Centrepoint Shopping Centre.

I have over the years written to the WA Police Commissioner with no reply to the matter and also various officers-in-charge at the Midland Police Station as well.

The area of Centrepoint Shopping Centre is an area for really bad antisocial behaviour and behind the Woolworths pickup point I have noticed arguments, screaming, fighting and people under the influence of substances.

It is on a daily basis  and is frightening for pedestrians walking past and drivers on the road as I have seen people walking in front of cars and recently I had to call Midland police as a woman was intoxicated and laying on the narrow strip between the car lanes.

The other day late in the afternoon I was riding my bike in the carpark of Centrepoint and noticed a security guard trying to calm down and remove a woman from that area who was angrily screaming abuse and would not leave.

I noticed a young woman close to me that was standing by her car with an empty pram.

I spoke to her and said I would stay with her thinking also that she was putting the pram back into her car.

She then took a baby out of her car into the pram and we walked around to the other side of the car where there was a small girl. When the child got out of the car she was shaking with fear.

This is not the first time at that shopping centre that a disorderly person has frightened a small child.

Basically, a parent goes shopping and their child is traumatised from an event out of their control.

There were three security guards on that day and I know they do the best in these circumstances.

Having more of a presence outside these areas with the bike police would greatly assist these antisocial behaviours and make shopping a good experience as well as being able to move safely around.

Don’t even get me started on a recent situation of a man coming down the escalators wildly waving a garden rake at the Midland Station.

I am aware when speaking to an officer at Midland Police Station that 24 hour move on notices are issued but that would be difficult to monitor.

I am fed-up with the attitude that its just Midland with these behaviours acceptable. That is not good enough and never should be.

I gather there is no longer a community policing unit at the Midland Police Station it is much needed and should never ever been taken away in the first place.

A Brown

Guildford

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Please remove rubbish

Dear Echo News,

Despite repeated phone calls  for more than four weeks the Mundaring Shire still won’t remove rubbish from an abandoned car, including needles putting local kids at risk at Greenmount.

Why is the shire so unresponsive and non-accountable to ratepayers?

No wonder few see the point of voting in council elections.

Dr C Hughes

Greenmount

Privately owned, proudly independent local news service.

ALL IMAGES & WORDS © 2023 Echo Newspaper
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram